"I believe I hate the British army more than any institution in being. My loathing for it is in exact proportion to my admiration for the men who fought at Senlac and Muratovizza. Forwhy, if you have conscription or landwehr, a man simply obeys the law; if the war is unjust, it is simply like obeying or enforcing any bad law. ... The fault rests not with him, but with those who send him. But in our army every man, officer and private, is there by his own choice. He is not consulted about that particular war; but he chose the man-slaying trade, when he might have chosen some other; so he is, what the conscript or landwehr man is not, responsible for being there. I grant that this is rather ideal; and, as circumstances go I don't rate the responsibility very high, if they only keep quiet. But when they came back, strutting and swaggering, talking as if they had done something to be proud of instead of ashamed, I hold that they made themselves accomplices with the Jew in the murther of the Zulus. ... I don't value skill or bravery, any more than height, strength, or beauty, unless they are used to a good purpose."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Historians from EnglandLiberal Party (UK) politiciansPeople from BirminghamUniversity of Oxford facultyUniversity of Oxford alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Letter to W. R. W. Stephens (8 March 1880), quoted in W. R. W. Stephens, The Life and Letters of Edward A. Freeman, Volume II (1895), pp. 198–199
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Edward_Augustus_Freeman
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Edward Augustus Freeman
(2 August 1823 – 16 March 1892) was an English historian, architectural artist, and Liberal politician during the late-19th-century heyday of Prime Minister of the United Kingdom William Ewart Gladstone, as well as a one-time candidate for Parliament. He held the position of Regius Professor of Modern History at Oxford, where he tutored Arthur Evans; later he and Evans would be activists in the Balkan uprising of Bosnia and Herzegovina (1874–1878) against the Ottoman Empire. After the marriage o
32 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Edward Augustus Freeman →
Related Quotes
"We must recognize the spirit which dictated the Petition of Right as the same which gathered all England around the b…"
"I must confess that I have never read W. Malmsb. de Pont. His Kings are enough to make me thoroughly despise him as a…"
"I have actually sat down to make a distinct History of the Norman Conquest, which I can do easier than anybody else, …"
"It seems to me that an age of belief sowed the good seed of which an age of unbelief, an age at least of less fervent…"
"Now the position for which I have always striven is this, that history is past politics, that politics are present hi…"
"I have no doubt that, if I had stood on the hill of Senlac, I should have felt a strong satisfaction in cleaving the …"
"Can any modern fox-hunter honestly say that his hunting is done with the legitimate object of getting rid of a noxiou…"
"I say then without hesitation that fox-hunting, which ages back may have been a praiseworthy means of ridding the cou…"
"[T]he risk of these sports, and the supposed manliness of facing that risk, is generally put forth as one of their me…"
"I cannot but think that the indulgence in cruelty in any form and in any degree must more or less harden the heart. I…"