"World War II, at least in Europe, may have had some moral justification, though there can be some legitimate debate as to whether the US and its freedoms were ever really threatened, and certainly many of the Americans who died in that war saw their struggle as worthy, so that we may at least in good conscience honor their deaths. But Khe Sanh? Mosul? And for god’s sake, Marjah? Let’s get real. Khe Sanh, one of the major battles in the Vietnam War, was just one little piece of a huge malignant disaster in a war that was criminal from its inception, and that had no purpose beyond perpetuating the neocolonialist control by the US of a long-subjugated people who were fighting to be free, just as our own ancestors had done. The over 58,000 Americans who died in that war, who contributed to the killing of over 2 million Vietnamese, many or most of them civilians, may have engaged in personal acts of bravery, but they were not, as a group, heroes. Nor were they over there fighting for American freedom. Some, like Lt. , who did not die, were no doubt murderers. Most, though, were simply victims–victims of their own government’s years of lying and deceit. If we memorialize them, it should be by vowing never again to allow our government to commit such crimes, and to send Americans to fight and die for such criminal policies. Sadly, we’ve already allowed that to happen, though, over and over again–in the Panama, in Grenada, in Iraq, and now in Afghanistan and perhaps, before long, Iran and/or Pakistan."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Non-fiction authors from the United StatesJournalists from the United StatesPolitical authorsPeople from ConnecticutInvestigative journalists
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Dave_Lindorff
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Dave Lindorff
11 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Dave Lindorff →
Related Quotes
"Khe Sanh, one of the major battles in the Vietnam War, was just one little piece of a huge malignant disaster in a wa…"
"According to some accounts, civilian deaths caused by America’s permanent war in the Middle East since 2001 could exc…"
"Add to that the other uncomfortable reality that many of the combatant deaths caused by US forces in places like Iraq…"
"And I am even sicker of politicians who wrap themselves in the bloody flag and try to rub off some of the stench of d…"
"President George W. Bush, who dodged danger in the Vietnam War by signing up for the Texas National Guard and then du…"
"After days of breathless reporting in the U.S. media about public and military support for Venezuelan President Nicol…"
"Take the president’s mention of . It is a city in Iraq, and the Americans who died there and in other Iraqi cities di…"
"As for Marjah, its mention at all in the same breath as the American Revolution or the Civil War is truly grotesque. …"
"If and when America and American freedom are really threatened, I have no doubt that American men and women will rise…"
"I’ll grant you that there were noble motivations that led many Americans to die fighting for this country’s independe…"