"Riemann's fifth proposition... This pernicious fallacy is one of the traditional errors current among mathematicians, and has been prolific of innumerable delusions. It is this error which has stood in the way of the formation of a rational, intelligible, and consistent theory of irrational and imaginary quantities, so called, and has shrouded the true principles of the doctrine of "complex numbers" and of the calculus of quaternions in an impenetrable haze. ... There are no "discrete quantities" except those which are dealt with in special (common) and general arithmetic, that is to say numbers. ...a number is not a quantity at all, nor a measure of quantity, but simply an intellectual vehicle of quantities—a purely subjective instrumentality for their comparison and admeasurement. ...quantities have been first divided into extensive quantities (space) and intensive quantities (forces, colors, sounds, and all subjective affections), and the extensive quantities have then been subdivided into continuous and discrete. Now, the fact is that all objects of apprehension, including all data of sense, are in themselves, i.e., within the act of apprehension, essentially continuous. They become discrete only by being subjected, arbitrarily or necessarily, to several acts of apprehension, and by thus being severed into parts, or coördinated with other objects similarly apprehended into wholes. To say that a datum of sensation or of subjective feeling is in itself discrete is to assert that it is absolute, and to deny that quantity is essentially relative. And to maintain (with those who speak of positive, negative, fractional, irrational, imaginary, complex, linear, or directional numbers) that number may be continuous is to ignore the plainest and most unmistakable fact in all our intellectual operations, and to misinterpret all the teachings of the history of mathematics. ...It is not to be expected... that mathematicians will cease, at this late day, to speak of arithmetical or algebraic symbols as "quantities;" but there may be a little hope... that they might return to the old phrase "geometrical (and other) magnitudes." The mischief lies, not so much in the use of a particular word, as in the employment of the same word for the denotation of objects differing from each other toto genera."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bernhard_Riemann
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Bernhard Riemann
Georg Friedrich Bernhard Riemann (September 17, 1826 – July 20, 1866) was an influential German mathematician who made lasting and revolutionary contributions to analysis, number theory, and differential geometry.
69 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Bernhard Riemann →
Related Quotes
"As is known, scientific physics dates its existence from the discovery of the differential calculus. Only when it was…"
"Magnitude-notions are only possible where there is an antecedent general notion which admits of different specialisat…"
"Definite portions of a manifoldness, distinguished by a mark or by a boundary, are called Quanta. Their comparison wi…"
"If in the case of a notion whose specialisations form a continuous manifoldness, one passes from a certain specialisa…"
"Measure-relations can only be studied in abstract notions of quantity, and their dependence on one another can only b…"
"For Space, when the position of points is expressed by rectilinear co-ordinates, ds = \sqrt{ \sum (dx)^2 }; Space is …"
"Let us imagine that from any given point the system of shortest lines going out from it is constructed; the position …"
"With every simple act of thinking, something permanent, substantial, enters our soul. This substantial somewhat appea…"
"Mind-masses entering the soul appear to us as ideas, the quality of the latter depending on the inner state of the fo…"
"Nevertheless, it remains conceivable that the measure relations of space in the infinitely small are not in accordanc…"