history-of-religion

"The Gods are not of Rome or Italy: They dwell in earth's abyss or with the stars, Their shrines are where we bring heroic hearts: Yet there are spots which to the minds of men Seem set apart for converse with the Gods. On temples by the sea our fancy roams To Hercules the Roamer: on high hills Astarte pours her radiance: Tanais bends Her bow in tempests, and the thunder hails Chrysaor's sword-flash. On this sultry marge Of nether night and Hades, let us bow Before the Powers of Silence, Death and Dreams; Of that chaotic Air that, o'er the deep Long brooding, brought forth lightnings in the sky; And of the Fires pent up, ere Æon rose, Parent of all our world, nor first nor last."

"They [the Pythagoreans] say the things themselves are Numbers and do not place the objects of mathematics between forms and sensible things. ...Since again, they saw that the modifications and the ratios of the musical scales were expressible in numbers—since, then, all other things seemed in their whole nature to be modelled on numbers, and numbers seemed to be the first things in the whole of nature, they supposed the elements of numbers to be the elements of all things, and the whole heaven to be a musical scale and a number... and the whole arrangement of the heavens they collected and fitted into their scheme; and if there was a gap anywhere, they readily made additions so as to make their whole theory coherent."

"The Pythagorean Order was simply, in its origin, a religious fraternity... and not, as has sometimes been maintained, a political league. Nor had it anything to do with the "Dorian aristocratic ideal." Pythagoras was an Ionian, and the Order was originally confined to Achaian states. Nor is there the slightest evidence that the Pythagoreans favoured the aristocratic rather than the democratic party. The main purpose... was to secure for... members a more adequate satisfaction of the religious instinct than... the State religion. It was... an institution for the cultivation of holiness. ...[I]t resembled an Orphic society, though it seems that Apollo, rather than Dionysos, was the chief Pythagorean god. That is doubtless why the Krotoniates identified Pythagoras with Apollo Hyperboreios. ...[H]owever, an independent society within a Greek state was apt to be brought into conflict with the larger body. The only way in which it could then assert its right to exist was... by securing the control of the sovereign power. The history of the Pythagorean Order... is, accordingly, the history of an attempt to supersede the State..."

"They thought they found in numbers, more than in fire, earth, or water, many resemblances to things which are and become; thus such and such an attribute of numbers is justice, another is soul and mind, another is opportunity, and so on; and again they saw in numbers the attributes and ratios of the musical scales. Since, then, all other things seemed in their whole nature to be assimilated to numbers, while numbers seemed to be the first things in the whole of nature, they supposed the elements of numbers to be the elements of all things, and the whole heaven to be a musical scale and a number."

"It has fallen to the lot of one people, the ancient Greeks, to endow human thought with two outlooks on the universe neither of which has blurred appreciably in more than two thousand years. ...The first was the explicit recognition that proof by deductive reasoning offers a foundation for the structure of number and form. The second was the daring conjecture that nature can be understood by human beings through mathematics, and that mathematics is the language most adequate for idealizing the complexity of nature into appreciable simplicity. Both are attributed by persistent Greek tradition to Pythagoras in the sixth century before Christ. ...there is an equally persistent tradition that it was Thales... who first proved a theorem in geometry. But there seems to be no claim that Thales... proposed the inerrant tactic of definitions, postulates, deductive proof, theorem as a universal method in mathematics. ...in attributing any specific advance to Pythagoras himself, it must be remembered that the Pythagorean brotherhood was one of the world's earliest unpriestly cooperative scientific societies, if not the first, and that its members assigned the common work of all by mutual consent to their master."

"None of Pythagoras' own work has survived, but the ideas fathered on him by his followers would be the most potent in modern history. Pure knowledge, the Pythagoreans argued, was the purification (catharsis) of the soul... rising above the data of the human senses. The pure essential reality... was found only in the realm of numbers. The simple, wonderful proportion if numbers would explain the harmonies of music... [T]hey introduced the musical terminology of the octave, the fifth, the fourth, expressed as 2:1, 3:1, and 4:3. ..."

"The Neo-Pythagoreans treated all the divisions of philosophy. In Metaphysics they held that the Unit and the (indeterminate) Two are the basis of all things. the Unit being the form, and the Two the matter. ...The Unit being the prior principle may be identified with Deity, and, as such, was thought of either as the former [creator] of indefinite matter into individual things, or, as in Neo-Platonism, as the transcendent origin of the derivative Unit and Two. Another mode of conception was to identify the numbers with the Platonic Ideas and then to think of the Unit as comprehending them in the same manner as the mind comprehends its thoughts and gives them form. In Logic the Neo-Pythagoreans were for the most part imitators of Aristotle. Their Physics was Aristotelian and Stoic. Their Anthropology was Platonic. In Ethics and Politics they merely reechoed the Academy and the Lyceum with Stoic additions. In all this Neo-Pythagoreanism has little originality."

"The Pythagorean mathematical concepts, abstracted from sense impressions of nature, were... projected into nature and considered to be the structural elements of the universe. [Pythagoreans] attempted to construct the whole heaven out of numbers, the stars being... material points. ...they identified the regular geometric solids... with the different sorts of substances in nature. ...This confusion of the abstract and the concrete, of rational conception and empirical description, which was characteristic of the whole Pythagorean school and of much later thought, will be found to bear significantly on the development of the concepts of calculus. It has often been inexactly described as mysticism, but such stigmatization appears to be somewhat unfair. Pythagorean deduction a priori having met with remarkable success in its field, an attempt (unwarranted...) was made to apply it to the description of the world of events, in which the Ionian hylozoistic interpretations a posteriori had made very little headway. This attack on the problem was highly rational and not entirely unsuccessful, even though it was an inversion of the scientific procedure, in that it made induction secondary to deduction."

"Ionian philosophers... had sought to identify a first principle for all things. Thales had thought to find this in water, but others preferred to think of air or fire as the basic element. The Pythagoreans had taken a more abstract direction, postulating that number... was the basic stuff behind phenomena; this numerical atomism... had come under attack by the followers of Parmenides of Elea... The fundamental tenet of the was the unity and permanence of being... contrasted with the Pythagorean ideas of multiplicity and change. Of Parmenides' disciples the best known was Zeno the Eleatic... who propounded arguments to prove the inconsistency in the concepts of multiplicity and divisibility."

"We may... go to our... statement from Aristotle's treatise on the Pythagoreans, that according to them the universe draws in from the Unlimited time and breath and the void. The cosmic nucleus starts from the unit-seed, which generates mathematically the number-series and physically the distinct forms of matter. ...it feeds on the Unlimited outside and imposes form or limit on it. Physically speaking this Unlimited is [potential or] unformed matter... mathematically it is extension not yet delimited by number or figure. ...As apeiron in the full sense, it was... duration without beginning, end, or internal division—not time, in Plutarch's words, but only the shapeless and unformed raw material of time... As soon... as it had been drawn or breathed in by the unit, or limiting principle, number is imposed on it and at once it is time in the proper sense. ...the Limit, that is the growing cosmos, breathed in... imposed form on sheer extension, and by developing the heavenly bodies to swing in regular, repetitive circular motion... it took in the raw material of time and turned it into time itself."

"It is certain that the Theory of Numbers originated in the school of Pythagoras."

"Those who dwelt in the common auditorium adopted this oath: "I swear by the discoverer of the Tetraktys, which is the spring of all our wisdom; The perennial fount and root of Nature.""

"The tetrad was called by the Pythagoreans every number, because it comprehends in itself all the numbers as far as to the decad, and the decad itself; for the sum of 1, 2, 3, and 4, is 10. Hence both the decad and the tetrad were said by them to be every number; the decad indeed in energy, but the tetrad in capacity. The sum likewise of these four numbers was said by them to constitute the tetractys, in which all harmonic ratios are included. For 4 to 1, which is a quadruple ratio, forms the symphony bisdiapason; the ratio of 3 to 2, which is sesquialter forms the symphony diapente; 4 to 3, which is sesquitertian, the symphony diatessaron; and 2 to 1, which is a duple ratio, forms the diapason."

"Nicomachus... mentions the customary Pythagorean divisions of quantum and the science that deals with each. Quantum is either discrete or continuous. Discrete quantum in itself considered, is the subject of Arithmetic; if in relation, the subject of Music. Continuous quantum, if immovable, is the subject of Geometry; if movable, of Spheric (Astronomy). These four sciences formed the of the Pythagoreans. With the (which Nicomachus does not mention) of Grammar, Logic, and Rhetoric, they composed the seven liberal arts taught in the schools of the Roman Empire."

"In Copernicus' time Pythagoreans still believed that the only way to truth was by mathematics."

"Why was the Tetraktys so revered? Because to the eyes of the sixth century BC Pythagoreans, it seemed to outline the entire nature of the universe. In geometry — the springboard to the Greeks' epochal revolution in thought — the number 1 represented a point... 2 represented a line... 3 represented a surface... and 4 represented a three-dimensional tetrahedral solid... The Tetraktys, therefore appeared to encompass all the perceived dimensions of space."

"On the question whether mathematics was discovered or invented, Pythagoras and the Pythagoreans had no doubt — mathematics was real, immutable, omnipresent, and more sublime than anything that could conceivably emerge from the human mind. The Pythagoreans literally embedded the universe into mathematics. In fact, to the Pythagoreans, God was not a mathematician — mathematics was God! ...By setting the stage, and to some extent the agenda, for the next generation of philosophers — Plato in particular — the Pythagoreans established a commanding position in Western thought."

"As a moral philosopher, many of his precepts relating to the conduct of life will be found in the verses which bear the name of the Golden Verses of Pythagoras. It is probable they were composed by some one of his school, and contain the substance of his moral teaching. The speculations of the early philosophers did not end in the investigation of the properties of number and space. The Pythagoreans attempted to find, and dreamed they had found, in the forms of geometrical figures and in certain numbers, the principles of all science and knowledge, whether physical or moral. The figures of Geometry were regarded as having reference to other truths besides the mere abstract properties of space. They regarded the unit, as the point; the duad, as the line; the triad, as the surface; and the tetractys, as the geometrical volume. They assumed the pentad as the physical body with its physical qualities. They seem to have been the first who reckoned the elements to be five in number, on the supposition of their derivation from the five regular solids. They made the cube, earth; the pyramid, fire; the octohedron, air; the icosahedron, water; and the dodecahedron, aether. The analogy of the five senses and the five elements was another favourite notion of the Pythagoreans."

"Almost all the theories, religious philosophical and mathematical, taught by the Pythagoreans, were known in India in the sixth century BCE, and the Pythagoreans, like the Jains and the Buddhists, refrained from the destruction of life and eating meat."

"While most s emphasized the reality of change — in particular, the Atomists, followers of and Democritus — the Pythagoreans stressed the study of the unchangeable elements in nature and society. In their search for the eternal laws of the universe they studied geometry, arithmetic, astronomy, and music (the '). Their most outstanding leader was Archytas of Tarentum...and to whose school, if we follow... E. [Eva] Frank, much of the Pythagorean brand of mathematics may be ascribed. ...Numbers were divided into classes: odd, even, even-times-even, odd-times-odd, prime and composite, perfect, friendly, triangular, square, pentagonal, etc. ...Of particular importance was the ratio of numbers (logos, Lat. ratio). Equality of ratio formed a proportion. They discriminated between an arithmetical (2b = a + c), geometrical (b^2 = ac), and a harmonical (\frac{2}{b} = \frac{1}{a} + \frac{1}{c}) proportion that they interpreted philosophically and socially."

"The Pythagoreans knew some properties of s... how a plane can be filled by... regular triangles, squares, or regular hexagons, and space by cubes... [They] may also have known the regular oktahedron and dodekahedron—the latter figure because pyrite, found in Italy, crystallizes in dodekahedra, and models... date to Etruscan times."

"[T]he most striking result of the Greeks' faith that the world could be understood in terms of rational principles was the invention of abstract mathematics. The most grandiose ambition they conceived was to explain all the properties of Nature in arithmetical terms alone. This was the aim of the Pythagoreans... [T]hey... knew that the phenomena of the Heavens recurred in a cyclical manner; and... discovered ...that the sound of a vibrating string ...is simply related to the length ...and its 'harmonics' always go with simple fractional lengths. ...[S]ince the Pythagoreans were a religious brotherhood... they thought that this search would lead to more than explanations alone. If one discovered the mathematical harmonies in things, one should... discover how to put oneself in harmony with Nature. ...[T]hey had ...positive grounds for thinking that both astronomy and acoustics were at the bottom arithmetical; and the study of simple fractions was called 'music' right down until the late Middle Ages."

"It is usually maintained that the Platonic or Socratic philosophy, like the rest of Greek speculation, was original, indigenous, owing very little to any outside influence. But the quest and life and faith of Socrates were as un-Greek as anything could possibly be: that was one of the reasons why the Greeks killed him: the essence of his life belonged to a world unknown to them, and therefore dangerous in their eyes […] There is only one “philosopher” whose doctrines, both practical and theoretical, appear to have resembled Plato’s in spirit and aim as well as in substance; and that one is Pythagoras. It is noteworthy that Pythagoras is the only great thinker of Greece whom Plato never criticises, but of whom he speaks with the greatest deference and respect […] instancing him as the great example of a teacher whose teaching had in it living truth enough to inspire a band of devoted disciples, and to transform their lives as well as their beliefs. And every one of those doctrines, which we know formed the “gospel” of Pythagoras and of the Pythagorean brotherhood at Crotona, was an almost exact reproduction of the cardinal doctrines of the Indian Vidya and the Indian Yoga—so much so that Indian Vedantists today do not hesitate to claim Pythagoras as one of themselves, one of their great expounders, whose very name was only the Greek form of the Indian title Pitta Guru, or Father-Teacher.’"

"It has been no easy task to revise this volume in such a way as to make it more worthy of the favour with which it has been received. Most of it has had to be rewritten in the light of certain discoveries made since the publication of the first edition, above all, that of the extracts from Menon’s Iατρικά, which have furnished, as I believe, a clue to the history of Pythagoreanism."

"[T]he authority of Anaximenes was so great that both Leukippos and Demokritos adhered to his theory of a disc-like earth. ...This, in spite of the fact that the spherical form of the earth was already a commonplace in circles affected by Pythagoreanism."

"The main purpose of the Orgia was to "purify" the believer’s soul, and so enable it to escape from the "wheel of birth," and it was for... this end that the Orphics were organised in communities. Religious associations must have been known to the Greeks from a fairly early date; but the oldest of these were based... in theory, on the tie of kindred blood. What was new was the institution of communities to which any one might be admitted by initiation. This was, in fact, the establishment of churches, though there is no evidence that these were connected... such... that we could rightly speak of them as a single church. The Pythagoreans came nearer to realising that."

"[T]he religious revival... suggested the view that philosophy was above all a "way of life." Science too was a "purification," a means of escape from the "wheel." This is the view expressed so strongly in Plato’s Phaedo, which was written under the influence of Pythagorean ideas."

"The Phaedo is dedicated... to Echekrates and the Pythagorean society at Phleious, and it is evident that Plato in his youth was impressed by the religious side of Pythagoreanism, though the influence of Pythagorean science is not clearly marked till a later period."

"[A] good many fragments of... Aristoxenos and Dikaiarchos are embedded in the mass. These writers were both disciples of Aristotle; they were natives of Southern Italy, and contemporary with the last generation of the Pythagorean school. Both wrote accounts of Pythagoras; and Aristoxenos, who was personally intimate with the last representatives of scientific Pythagoreanism, also made a collection of the sayings of his friends."

"There is no reason to believe that the detailed statements which have been handed down with regard to the organisation of the Pythagorean Order rest upon any historical basis... The distinction of grades within the Order, variously called Mathematicians and Akousmatics, Esoterics and Exoterics, Pythagoreans and Pythagorists, is an invention designed to explain how there came to be two widely different sets of people, each calling themselves disciples of Pythagoras, in the fourth century B.C. So, too, the statement that the Pythagoreans were bound to inviolable secrecy, which goes back to Aristoxenos, is intended to explain why there is no trace of the Pythagorean philosophy proper before Philolaos."

"These thinkers seem to consider that number is the principle both as matter for things and as constituting their attributes and permanent states."

"When discussing the Pythagorean system, Aristotle always refers it to "the Pythagoreans," not to Pythagoras himself. ...[T]his was intentional ...Pythagoras himself is only thrice mentioned in the whole Aristotelian corpus, and in only one... is any philosophical doctrine ascribed to him. ...Aristotle ...is quite clear that what he knew as the Pythagorean system belonged in the main to the days of Empedokles, Anaxagoras, and Leukippos; for ...he goes on to describe the Pythagoreans as "contemporary with and earlier than them.""

"The Pythagoreans held, [Aristotle] tells us that there was "boundless breath" outside the heavens, and that it was inhaled by the world. In substance, this is the doctrine of Anaximenes, and... it was that of Pythagoras... Xenophanes denied it. ...[F]urther development of the idea is ...due to Pythagoras ...We are told that, after the first unit had been formed ...the nearest part of the Boundless was first drawn in and limited; and... the Boundless thus inhaled... keeps the units separate from each other. It represents the interval between them. This is a... primitive way of describing... discrete quantity."

"In... Aristotle... the Boundless is also... the void or empty. This identification of air and the void is a confusion... in Anaximenes... too. We find also... the other confusion... air and vapour. ...Pythagoras identified the Limit with fire, and the Boundless with darkness. We are told by Aristotle that Hippasos made Fire the first principle... Parmenides... attributes... two primary "forms," Fire and Night. ...Light and Darkness appear in the Pythagorean table of opposites under the heads of the Limit and the Unlimited respectively."

"The identification of breath with darkness ...is a strong proof of the primitive character of the doctrine; for in the sixth century darkness was supposed ...a sort of vapour, while in the fifth, its true nature was ...known. Plato... makes the Pythagorean Timaios describe mist and darkness as condensed air."

"[T]hink, then, of a "field" of darkness or breath marked out by luminous units ...which the starry heavens would naturally suggest."

"It is... probable that we should ascribe to Pythagoras the Milesian view of a plurality of worlds, though... not... infinite ...Petron, one of the early Pythagoreans, said there were ...a hundred and eighty-three worlds arranged in a triangle; and Plato makes Timaios admit, when laying down ...only one world, that something might be urged in favour of ...five, as there are five regular solids."

"Simplicius, with the poem of Parmenides before him, corrects Aristotle by substituting Light and Darkness for Fire and Earth... Parmenides... calls one "form" Light, Flame, and Fire, and the other Night, and we... consider whether these can be identified with the Pythagorean Limit and Unlimited. We have... reason to believe that... the world breathing belonged to the earliest form of Pythagoreanism, and... identifying this "boundless breath" with Darkness, which stands... for the Unlimited. "Air" or mist was always regarded as the dark element. And that which gives definiteness to the vague darkness is... light or fire, and this may account for the prominence given to that element by Hippasos. We may probably conclude... that the Pythagorean distinction between the Limit and the Unlimited... made its first appearance in this crude form. If... we identify darkness with the Limit, and light with the Unlimited, as most critics do, we get into insuperable difficulties."

"In the fourth century, the chief seat of the school is at Taras, and we find the Pythagoreans heading the opposition to Dionysios of Syracuse. ...[In] this period... Archytas... the friend of Plato... almost realised, if he did not suggest, the ideal of the . ...He was also the inventor of mathematical mechanics."

"At the same time, Pythagoreanism had taken root in Hellas. Lysis... remained at Thebes, where Simmias and Kebes had heard Philolaos, and there was an important community of Pythagoreans at Phleious. Aristoxenos was personally acquainted with the last generation of the school, and mentioned by name Xenophilos the Chalkidian from , with Phanton, Echekrates, Diokles, and Polymnestos of Phleious. They were all, he said, disciples of Philolaos and Eurytos. Plato was on friendly terms with these men, and dedicated the Phaedo to them. Xenophilos was the teacher of Aristoxenos..."

"It seems natural to suppose... the Pythagorean elements of Plato’s Phaedo and Gorgias come mainly from Philolaos. Plato makes Sokrates express surprise that Simmias and Kebes had not learnt from him why it is unlawful for a man to take his [own] life, and it seems to be implied that the Pythagoreans at Thebes used the word "philosopher" in the... sense of... seeking to find... release from the burden of this life? It is... probable that Philolaos spoke of the body... as the tomb... of the soul. ...[H]e taught the old Pythagorean religious doctrine in some form, and... likely... laid stress upon knowledge as a means of release. ...Plato ...is by far the best authority ...on the subject."

"We know... Philolaos wrote on "numbers"; for Speusippos followed him in the account he gave of the Pythagorean theories on that subject. It is probable... he busied himself... with arithmetic, and... his geometry was... primitive... Eurytos was his disciple, and... his views were... crude."

"Philolaos wrote on medicine, and... while... influenced by the... Sicilian school, he opposed them from the Pythagorean standpoint. ...[H]e said... our bodies were composed only of the warm... [O]nly after birth... the cold was introduced by respiration. The connexion... with the old Pythagorean theory is obvious. Just as the Fire in the macrocosm draws in and limits the cold dark breath which surrounds the world... so do our bodies inhale cold breath... Philolaos made , blood, and the causes of disease..."

"Philolaos... is a sufficiently remarkable figure... and has... been spoken of as a "precursor of Copernicus.""

"Plato was intimate with these men and was deeply impressed by their religious teaching, though... he did not adopt it... He was still more attracted by the scientific side of Pythagoreanism, and... this exercised a great influence on him. His own system in its final form had many points of contact with it, as he is careful to mark in the ' But... he is apt to develop Pythagoreanism on lines of his own, which may or may not have commended themselves to Archytas, but are no guide to the views of Philolaos and Eurytos. He is not careful... to claim the authorship of his own improvements in the system. He did not believe that cosmology could be an exact science, and he... therefore... credit[s] Timaios the Lokrian, or "ancient sages"... with theories which... had their birth in the Academy."

"Plato had many enemies and detractors, and this literary device enabled them to bring against him the charge of plagiarism. Aristoxenos... made the extraordinary statement that most of the Republic was... found in a work by Protagoras. ...He seems also... the... source of the story that Plato bought "three Pythagorean books" from Philolaos and copied the Timaeus out of them. ...[A]ccounts... imply... Plato bought... either a book by Pythagoras, or... notes of his teaching..."

"We know nothing of Timaios except what Plato tells us... and he may... be a fictitious character like the Eleatic Stranger."

"We are told that the other book which passed under the name of Pythagoras was really by Lysis."

"[W]e have... testimony that the five "Platonic figures,"... were discovered in the Academy. In the to Euclid... Pythagoreans only knew the , the pyramid (), and the , while the and the were discovered by Theaitetos."

"It seems to me that they do well to study mathematics, and it is not at all strange that they have correct knowledge about each thing, what it is. For if they knew rightly the nature of the whole, they were also likely to see well what is the nature of the parts. About geometry, indeed, and arithmetic and astronomy, they have handed us down a clear understanding, and not least also about music. For these seem to be sister sciences; for they deal with sister subjects, the first two forms of being."