"Even when judges agree on the relevance of a past case to a present one, they may, and frequently do, disagree about how the applicable precedent should be read. Thus judges construct law’s own history in the process of deciding present cases. They do so through a complex genealogical operation that accords them enormous discretion, and yet allows them to claim that they are fully and completely bound by the past. In law “the past is primarily a source of authority”-if we interpret it correctly, it will tell us how to conduct ourselves now. History is not only a source of authority but of legitimacy.” Reading and decoding the past, arguing about its meaning, and shaping decisions as if they were the inexorable product of an uncontested history is the very stuff of law. Judges make history anew with each opinion, all the while proclaiming that they are simply discovering a past whose significance is, or should be, self-evident."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
p.5 quoting Robert Gordon, “Foreword: The Arrival of Critical Historicism,” Stanford Law Review (1997), 49:1023.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Precedents
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Precedents
47 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Precedents →
Related Quotes
"The right hon. Gentleman tells us to go back to precedents; with him a great measure is always founded on a small pre…"
"I am ready to concede that the rule of adherence to precedent, though it ought not to be abandoned, ought to be in so…"
"What has once been settled by a precedent will not be unsettled overnight, for certainty and uniformity are gains not…"
"The repetition of a catchword can hold analysis in fetters for fifty years or more."
"If Napoleon had nuclear subs, we'd all be speaking French. So, the history thing can be oversold."
"An avidity to punish is always dangerous to liberty. It leads men to stretch, to misinterpret, and to misapply even t…"
"What is today supported by precedents will hereafter become a precedent."
"Ages, precedents, have long been accumulating undirected materials, America brings builders, and brings its own style…"
"The most obvious example of the way law constructs and uses history is found in the doctrine of stare decisis and the…"
"PRECEDENT, n. In Law, a previous decision, rule or practice which, in the absence of a definite statute, has whatever…"