"As a jarring illustration of our tendency to value the human side over the prerequisite physical/ecological side, imagine that somehow we manage to emerge from the coming centuries having established a truly sustainable existence. All resources are renewed by nature at the rate of extraction for human needs; population is steady and at a level just tolerable to the planet in terms of indefinite support. Diverse ecosystems are left to thrive in their natural states. But imagine that we are still plagued by cancer and other maladies, so that life expectancy is, say, 90 years. Then what if a team of researchers hits on a cure for (most forms of) cancer? Hurray! At last! Unambiguously good, right? Well, not so fast. All other elements held the same, longer life spans translate to a higher population, putting additional resource burdens on the planet that it cannot handle in the long term. In order to adopt and implement the cure for cancer, we would have to either deliberately reduce population or lower the standard of living to accommodate the change. All other considerations of the complex society about economic impacts, equity of distribution, legal and political facets, or interaction with religious belief systems must take a back seat to the most fundamental and important question: is this change physically viable on this finite planet in the long term?"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Thomas W. Murphy, "Caught Up in Complexity". Do the Math, . November 30, 2021.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Overpopulation
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Overpopulation
208 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Overpopulation →
Related Quotes
"In 1800, every human on the planet had a corresponding 80 kg of mammal mass in the wild. Wildland mammals outweighed …"
"Energy has been fundamental to our story of growth. The various hockey stick curves over the last century or so are a…"
"Our fossil fuel bonanza has left our ecosystem in a perilous state. We have destroyed vast forests and habitats, poll…"
"The human explosion has accelerated across the millennia, most recently reaching a fever pitch owing to the employmen…"
"Population estimates are usually based on demographic data alone with no consideration of exogenous factors. This is …"
"As if the Enlightenment was not enough, in quick succession we joined another enormous river. One could say that the …"
"Given the Maoist position that a large population was a “resource”, rather than a burden, for the Communist state, it…"
"What did we do with our fossil fuel bonanza? We exploded population by revolutionizing agriculture [and health]. Now …"
"…fossil fuels allowed us to drastically overshoot the natural carrying capacity of the planet, and that bill will com…"
"We have used [fossil fuels] to expand the human enterprise and population, knock down forests, destroy and fragment h…"