"Why do the secularists never comment on such material? Where do the fatwas leave the ecumenical homilies of our Sarva dharma samabhava school? The fatwas of the ‘nationalist’ ulema were surprising enough: they urged joint action with kafirs on strictly pragmatic grounds, on the ground in particular that such joint action was the best, indeed the only available way to maintain separateness. But here we have fatwas which proclaim even that pragmatism to be kufr. Notice that the person in question, the one whose leadership occasioned the fatwas was Mahatma Gandhi—a more saintly person is not likely to be available in our public life for decades and decades. And yet these were the fatwas. The cause too was as noble as a cause can be—the country’s Independence. Often—as during the Khilafat movement—the cause was of direct concern to the Muslims. And yet these were the fatwas. Notice too that while, for urging even that minimal cooperation with the kafir Hindus, an alim even of the eminence of Mufti Kifayatullah had to confine himself to pragmatic reasoning, Maulana Ahmad Riza Khan was able to justify his fatwas by citing chapter and verse from the Quran and Hadis. For the Quran and Hadis ordain the position elaborated by Ahmad Riza Khan, and not the one the ‘nationalist’ ulema strained to justify. That is the fact which our intelligentsia does not want to face."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Arun Shourie - The World of Fatwas Or The Sharia in Action (2012, Harper Collins)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Muslim_nationalism_in_South_Asia
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Muslim nationalism in South Asia
7 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Muslim nationalism in South Asia →
Related Quotes
"What was the difference between Jinnah and the nationalist Muslims? While Jinnah wanted a separate state, the nationa…"
"Some of them, particularly of Ulema class, sounded a warning that Pakistan might impede the establishment of Dinia by…"
"The Qaid-e-Azam had two sets of teeth in his mouth like that of a rogue elephant — one set was for show of beauty, an…"
"These fatwas ... are the fatwas of the leading light of what would today be called the nationalist ulema: they reflec…"
"The Moslems in general and Indian Moslems in particular have not as yet grown out of the historical stage, of intense…"
"The foundation of the Muslim League and Minto’s concessions had the effect of dividing the Hindus and Muslims into al…"
"On February 11 Congress Party Chairwoman Sonia Gandhi traveled to the Northeast Indian state of Assam to inaugurate h…"
"The Congress government, which passed the IMDT Act in 1983, has been accused of catering to mostly-Muslim Bangladeshi…"
"As more migrants gained the right to vote, they quickly became a protected vote bank for Congress and Communist parti…"
"Those in power, regardless of organisation or ideology, are distorting history. It is well known and no secret. A cou…"