"But the point, as I argued with Caplan, is not that managers are inherently less intelligent or capable as individuals. Rather, it’s that hierarchical organizations are—to borrow that wonderful phrase from Feldman and March—systematically stupid. For all the same Hayekian reasons that make a planned economy unsustainable, no individual is “smart” enough to manage a large, hierarchical organization. Nobody–not Einstein, not John Galt–possesses the qualities to make a bureaucratic hierarchy function rationally. Nobody’s that smart, any more than anybody’s smart enough to run Gosplan efficiently–that’s the whole point. No matter how insightful and resourceful they are, no matter how prudent, as human beings in dealing with actual reality, nevertheless by their very nature hierarchies insulate those at the top from the reality of what’s going on below, and force them to operate in imaginary worlds where all their intelligence becomes useless. No matter how intelligent managers are as individuals, a bureaucratic hierarchy makes their intelligence less usable."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Anarchists from the United StatesEssayists from the United StatesSocial anarchistsEconomists from the United StatesBloggers
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Homebrew Industrial Revolution (2010), Chapter 7.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Kevin_Carson
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Kevin Carson
20 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Kevin Carson →
Related Quotes
"In a very real sense, every subsidy and privilege ... is a form of slavery. Slavery, simply put, is the use of coerci…"
"The natural effect of unfettered market competition is socialism. For a short time the innovator receives a large pro…"
"When that happens, and the “World’s Sole Remaining Superpower” loses its early-adopter advantage, drone technology wi…"
". The central theme of contemporary autonomist Marxism is a shift from giant organizations and insurrectional seizure…"
"The key to efficiency, for the New Class, was to remove as much of life as possible from the domain of "politics" (th…"
"Vulgar libertarian apologists for capitalism use the term "free market" in an equivocal sense: they seem to have trou…"
"The great investors are almost entirely clueless as to what their supposed “employees,” the corporation managers are …"
"We have probably already passed a “singularity,” a point of no return, in the use of networked information warfare. I…"
"The shift to the pre‐job pattern of self‐employment in the informal sector promises to eliminate this pathological cu…"
"Localized, small‐scale economies are the rats in the dinosaurs’ nests. The informal and household economy operates mo…"