"Schinkel had asserted that architecture should be the expression of an idea, and, that insofar as it represented a transcendence of the intellectual over purely material considerations, the Gothic style was the best example of an architectural expression of ideas. Yet, as it happened over the next several generations Gothic was capable of expressing a variety of ideas, often contradictory. It could, for example, express the ultimate victory of spirit over matter, an architectural system "organically" related to nature, or the most logical and efficient use of masonry. It was both the visible expression of the Germanic soul and an ideal vehicle for Catholic worship. If similar forms could express such a variety of ideas, was it also possible that a variety of forms could express similar ideas? That meaning was not intrinsic in the forms but rather attached to them by tacit agreement and confirmed by the specific context? Although it is true that the Gothic Monument to the Wars of Liberation was in a "national" style while the Museum dedicated to universal cultural history was in a timeless "international" style, there is also the particular location of each building to consider: a suburban hilltop for the former and the center of the city with its monumental classical buildings for the latter. Schinkel approached each particular problem on its own terms, and this freedom from a self-consistent but doctrinaire method contributed to his success as a practicing architect even if it makes it difficult to reconstruct his "theory of architecture.""
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Rand Carter in "Karl Friedrich Schinkel, The Last Great Architect" (1981)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Karl_Friedrich_Schinkel
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Karl Friedrich Schinkel
1781 – 1841
deutscher Architekt, BegrĂĽnder der [[w:Schinkelschule|Schinkelschule]]
16 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Karl Friedrich Schinkel →
Related Quotes
"Schinkel's aesthetic was not a crudely materialistic "truth to material" affair… but rather an attempt to inform iron…"
"Ironically, the belief that the new age was essentially different from the past led to the emotional need to find "ro…"
"Schinkel was not arbitrary in his use of historical modes but rather eclectic in the best sense of the word. He could…"
"Erst erfreuen, dann belehren."
"I hope I may be allowed to remark that recent inventions and improvements enabling works of art to be duplicated fait…"
"Indifference to the fine arts comes close to barbarism."
"Das Nützliche und Nothwendige, so gut es an sich ist, wird widrig wenn es ohne Anstand und Würde auftritt, und zu die…"
"„Eine Skizze wirkt oft so viel mehr und höher als die Ausführung, weil in letztere vieles aufgenommen wird, was man f…"
"„Mode kann jeder unvernünftige Einfall werden; wo Mode vorherrscht, ist es immer ein Zeichen von Mangel an Freiheitsb…"
"„Es gibt auch eine Rückwirkung der schönen Kunst auf die Moral; die Freiheit der Empfindung überhaupt, durch bestimmt…"