"Unlike the authors of these now-familiar narratives, Barkley sometimes relished combat, and he made no apology for having dispatched scores of enemy soldiers. in short, his perspective did not line up with accepted wisdom (at least among artists and intellectuals) about how the soldiers of the Great War were supposed to remember their experience. Like Germany's Ernst Jünger, whose controversial memoir Storm of Steel (1921) shares many similarities with No Hard Feelings!, Barkley was something of a war lover- or, as the dust jacket for the first edition of his memoir put it, one of those "warriors... who fight and like it." Other literary commentators on the Great War- like Richard Aldington, Siegfried Sassoon, William March, and Thomas Boyd- emphasized the powerlessness of soldiers on the modern battlefield, as poison gas, high explosives, and machine guns reduced battle to a senseless lottery. In contrast, while acknowledging lost comrades, Barkley celebrated toughness and aggression. And based on his own experience, he remained convinced that individual effort had made a difference even in this most industrialized and seemingly impersonal of conflicts. His chronicle of battlefield endurance and will come as something of a surprise to readers today- a precursor to Audie Murphy's To Hell and Back (1949), set during a war that if we are to believe the canonical literature offered only impersonal carnage."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Steven Trout, Introduction to Scarlet Fields (2012), p. 2-3
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_L._Barkley
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
John L. Barkley
John Lewis Barkley (August 28, 1895 – April 14, 1966) was a United States Army Medal of Honor recipient of World War I. Born in Blairstown, Missouri, near Holden, Barkley served as a Private First Class in Company K, 4th Infantry Regiment, 3rd Division. He earned the medal while fighting near Cunel, France, on October 7, 1918.
15 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by John L. Barkley →
Related Quotes
"Everybody around me was going crazy about the war. I was under age- eighteen- but with as bad a case of war fever as …"
"Ever since I'd learned to talk- or tried to learn- my stuttering had made a barrier between me and other people. It h…"
"Early in April we drew extra equipment. At one o'clock the next morning we were waked up and ordered to pack. Then we…"
"Sometime in May we began to have a feeling that our days of preparation were nearly over. We'd find officers standing…"
"That afternoon we took Le Charmel. There weren't many of us left."
"I didn't like those intervals between fighting. They gave me too much time to think. And my thoughts were getting pre…"
"A tall officer mounted a little platform that had been set up to our front. I'd never seen him before, but I knew him…"
"At last General Pershing finished his speech and climbed down from his platform. He came straight toward Lieutenant H…"
"General Sladen told me then that I could stand at ease, and I was altogether more comfortable physically than I'd bee…"
"When the decorating part of the ceremony was over they marched us around and placed us on the reviewing line behind G…"