"This shameless advocacy of cancel culture, moreover for a theory that was long the most accepted one, is an attitude that has gained ground among professional Indo-Europeanists, as I have had to find out many times personally. A consequence is for instance that Joanna Nichols and Claus Peter Zoller have, after Shrikant Talageri pointed out the pro-OIT implications of their findings (that the pattern of lexical borrowing in West-Asian languages from Indo-European indicated that this family came from the east, Bactria or so; c.q. that the Bangani dialect in North India shows a substrate of a kentum Indo-European language similar to the family’s westernmost branches), declared that their findings remain valid but not these pro-OIT implications. In India, this is being laughed at as an Inquisition-like or Stalinist-like recanting."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Non-fiction authors from the United StatesLinguists from the United StatesPeople from IowaUniversity of California, Berkeley alumni
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Why Indo-Europeanists Have A Duty To Face The Out-Of-India Theory, 2022
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Johanna_Nichols
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Johanna Nichols
25 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Johanna Nichols →
Related Quotes
"These principles make it possible to pinpoint the locus in space more or less accurately even for a language family a…"
"Central Eurasia is a linguistic bottleneck, spread zone, and extinction chamber, but its languages had to come from s…"
"There are several linguistically plausible possibilities for the origin of Pre-PIE. It could have spread eastward fro…"
"And academics have come up with theories of their own. For example, Johanna Nichols, a professor of linguistics at th…"
"The archaeological sources on which this summary is based... most often describe the westward cultures as derived fro…"
"No migrations are required to derive the attested IE distribution from a reconstructed homeland consisting of a locus…"
"The vast interior of Eurasia is a linguistic spread zone—a genetic and typological bottleneck where many genetic line…"
"It is a basic tenet of migration and homeland theory that the geographical location of a language family’s proto-home…"
"The Iranian family, which was next to sweep across the steppe and deserts, finds its region of greatest diversity in …"
"She holds that the dispersal of the Indo-European languages commenced from a region somewhere in the vicinity of anci…"