"Along the same lines, the antiquities discovered at Quetta in 1985, which are also sometimes connected with intruding Indo-Aryans (i.e., e.g. Allchin 1995), can also simply be viewed as reflecting "the economic dynamism of the area extending from South Central Asia to the Indus Valley." The fact that similar objects are also found in graves and deposits in northern Iran, eastern Iran, northwestern Afghanistan, South Turkmenia, and Baluchistan might simply indicate "a wide distribution of common beliefs and ritual practices" (Jarrige and Hassan (1985) 1989, 162-163). Jarrige and Hassan reject the idea that these finds were associated with invaders related to the Hissar III C complex, since "there is nothing in the Gorgan Plain and at Hissar to prove that northern Iran has been a relay station for invading people. The . . . grey ware can very well be explained within its local context" (163-164). Nor are these scholars partial to the northern steppe Andronov alternatives, since: We leave to the linguists the problem of whether Indo-European languages were introduced into the Middle Asian regions from a still unknown part of the Eurasian steppes in the course of the third millennium or if Indo-Iranian languages have been associated with these regions for a much longer period. As far as archaeology is concerned, we do think that it is increasingly necessary for specialists in Indo-lranian studies to pay attention to the . . . interrelated cultural entities of the late third and early second millennium in the regions between Mesopotamia and the Indus. It is a direction of research that is likely to be more fruitful than are traditional attempts to locate remains left by nomads from "the Steppes," attempts that were in fashion when the Indo-Iranian Borderlands were thought to be a cultural vacuum. (164)"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
in Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press. chapter 10
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Jean-Fran%C3%A7ois_Jarrige
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Jean-François Jarrige
12 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Jean-François Jarrige →
Related Quotes
"Although basic similarities exist, linking Mehrgarh with comparable Levantine and Zagrosian aceramic neolithic groups…"
"Another element of continuity between ceramics of the third millennium Baluchistan and those of the second millennium…"
"Phoenix-like, the theory of the invaders, preferably Indo-Europeans, always rises from its ashes."
"Despite inviting linguists to reconsider the northern steppe hypothesis in favor of the southern route, it can be inf…"
"Jarrige (1985) specifically mentions that the existence of the Indo-Aryans has "so far only been deduced on the basis…"
"From the Neolithic time till almost today there has never been, in spite of spectacular changes in the course of time…"
"‘This famous vacuum that was sometimes called Vedic night . . . has been filling up more and more thanks to numerous …"
"Nothing, in the present state of archaeological research ... enables us to reconstruct convincingly invasions that co…"
"To take a single example here, some scholars decided that the Pirak culture, which emerged around 1800 BCE in the pla…"
"As the excavator of Pirak, the only well-preserved second millennium B.C.E. site from the area (which he dates from 1…"