"In the autumn of 1878 [Heinrich Hertz] came to Berlin and it was as an university student there in the physical laboratory under my control that I first made his acquaintance. ...In Germany at that time the laws of electromagnetics were deduced by most physicists from the hypothesis of W. Weber, who sought to trace back electric and magnetic phenomena to a modification of Newton's assumption of direct forces acting at a distance and in a straight line. With increasing distance these forces diminish in accordance with the same laws as those assigned by Newton to the force of gravitation, and held by Coulomb to apply to the action between pairs of electrified particles. The force was directly proportional to the product of the two quantities of electricity, and inversely proportional to the square of their distance apart; like quantities produced repulsion, unlike quantities attraction. Furthermore, in Weber's hypothesis it was assumed that this force was propagated through infinite space instantaneously, and with infinite velocity. The only difference between the views of W. Weber and of Coulomb consisted in this—that Weber assumed that the magnitude of the force between the two quantities of electricity might be affected by the velocity with which the two quantities approached towards or receded from one another, and also by the acceleration of such velocity. Side by side with Weber's theory there existed a number of others, all of which... regarded the magnitude of the force expressed by Coulomb's law as being modified by the influence of some component of the velocity... Such theories were advanced by F. E. Neumann, by his son C. Neumann, by Riemann, Grassmann, and subsequently by Clausius. Magnetised molecules were regarded as the axes of circular electric currents, in accordance with an analogy between their external effects previously discovered by Ampère. This plentiful crop of hypotheses had become very unmanageable, and in dealing with them it was necessary to go through complicated calculations, resolutions of forces into their components in various directions, and so on. So at that time the domain of electromagnetics had become a pathless wilderness. Observed facts and deductions from exceedingly doubtful theories were inextricably mixed up together. With the object of clearing up this confusion I had set myself the task of surveying the region of electromagnetics, and of working out the distinctive consequences of the various theories, in order, wherever... possible, to decide between them by suitable experiments."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Hermann von Helmholtz, Introduction to Heinrich Hertz, The Principles of Mechanics Presented in a New Form (1899) Tr. D. E. Jones, J. T. Walley, pp. ix-x.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Electromagnetism
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Electromagnetism
45 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Electromagnetism →
Related Quotes
"Maxwell in particular noted that the phenomena of electromagnetism did not fit into the scheme of Newtonian mechanics…"
"Maxwell succeeded in casting all known electromagnetic effects into a mathematical form that has endured to this day.…"
"Faraday was the first scientist to realise the enormous importance of the electromagnetic field. He saw in it a reali…"
"In order to appreciate the nature of Maxwell's contributions, let us recall how matters stood in his day. ...Faraday'…"
"The... weak force... couples to both s and s, and is very short-ranged due to the large rest mass of the messenger qu…"
"The general equations are next applied to the case of a magnetic disturbance propagated through a non-conductive fiel…"
"Classical mechanics has been developed continuously from the time of Newton and applied to an ever-widening range of …"
"The first clear sign of a breakdown in communication between physics and mathematics was the extraordinary lack of in…"
"After ten years of reflection such a principle resulted from a paradox upon which I had already hit at the age of six…"
"The subject of electric oscillation announced in a remarkable paper of Henry in 1842 and threshed out in its main fea…"