"So, one can argue that insects are important, practically and economically, and one can argue that they bring us joy, inspiration and wonder, but both arguments are ultimately selfish, for both focus on what insects do for us. There is a final line of reasoning for looking after insects and the rest of the life on our planet, big and small, and it is one that is not focused on human well-being. One can argue that all of the organisms on Earth have as much right to be here as we do. If you are of a religious bent do you really think that God created all of this amazing life just so we could recklessly destroy it? Do you think He or She intended for coral reefs to be bleached and dead, littered with plastic trash? Does it seem plausible that He or She went to the trouble of creating five million species of insect so that we could drive many of them extinct without ever even registering their existence? If on the other hand you are not a believer, and accept the scientific evidence that species evolved over billions of years rather than being created by a supernatural being with a beetle obsession, then you must realize that we are just a particularly intelligent and destructive species of monkey, nothing more than one of the perhaps ten million species of animal and plant on Earth. In that view, nobody granted us dominion over the beasts; we have no God-given moral right to pillage, destroy and exterminate. Religious or not, most humans agree that the rich and powerful should not be allowed to oppress or dispossess the poor and powerless (though of course we do allow it to happen all the time). Similarly, in dozens of sci-fi movies from The War of the Worlds onwards, aliens more intelligent than ourselves arrive, decide that the human race is redundant, and set about wiping us out so they can plunder the Earth for their own ends, or build an interstellar bypass. Of course, in these films we see the aliens as the bad guys, and we root for the inferior humans who usually somehow triumph in the end despite the odds being stacked against them. When will we realise the hypocrisy of our position? On our own planet we are the bad guys, thoughtlessly annihilating life of all kinds for our own convenience. We intuitively grasp that the aliens of the movie Independence Day have no right to take our planet; I wonder what goes through the mind of an orang-utan as it sees its forest home bulldozed to the ground? There should not have to be a ‘point of slugs’ for us to allow them their existence. Do we not have a moral duty to look after our fellow travellers on planet Earth, beautiful or ugly, providing vital ecosystem services or utterly inconsequential, be they penguins, pandas, or silverfish?"
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Chapter 3, “The Wonder of Insects” (pp. 41-42; boldface added)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Dave_Goulson
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Dave Goulson
30 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Dave Goulson →
Related Quotes
"Ants alone outnumber us by about one million to one. Until perhaps the last 200 years, an alien looking down on Earth…"
"Why he was asked to comment on a subject on which he has no expertise is unclear, but in these strange times it seems…"
"Some previous deliberate introductions of non-native species to Australia had gone horribly wrong: for example, cane …"
"For me, the economic value of insects is just a tool with which to bash politicians over the head. They only seem to …"
"‘Normal’ is different for every generation."
"We are committing ecocide on a biblical scale. I am in no way religious, but if you are, consider this; do you really…"
"Insecticides kill all insects, not just the ones that they are aimed at, whatever the doublethinkers who manufacture …"
"These are beneficial creatures, and should be celebrated, not persecuted and poisoned in some misguided psychotic urg…"
"It is sometimes said that humanity is at war with nature, but the word ‘war’ implies a two-way conflict. Our chemical…"
"One theory as to why metamorphosis is such a successful strategy is that it enables the immature stages and the adult…"