"To be sure, neither Jones nor anyone else was wrong to perceive strong and systematic similarities among Sanskrit, Latin, Greek, and the rest. The question is what one makes of these similarities, and one steps onto a slippery slope whenever analysis moves from the descriptive to the historic plane of linguistics. In specific, reconstructing a "protolanguage" is an exercise that invites one to imagine speakers of that protolanguage, a community of such people, then a place for that community, a time in history, distinguishing characteristics, and a set of contrastive relations with other protocommunities where other protolanguages were spoken. For all of this, need it be said, there is no sound evidentiary warrant."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Lincoln, B. (1999). Theorizing myth: Narrative, ideology, and scholarship. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. p.95
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Bruce_Lincoln
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Bruce Lincoln
31 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Bruce Lincoln →
Related Quotes
"When one permits those whom one studies to define the terms in which they will be understood, suspends one’s interest…"
"It now strikes me that the attempt to reconstruct a prototypical (“Proto- Indo-European") form from which all atteste…"
"Even the unhappy example of scholarship on myth, particularly that on Aryan or Indo-European myth, is one forced to c…"
""As a student of history of religions, I (Lincoln) was taught that Fredric Max Muller inaugurated our discipline but …"
"Herder developed his theory of Asia as the original homeland and site of human unity in the second volume of his Idee…"
"Reading Jones with these preconceptions and interests, Germans rapidly came to see themselves as a Volk with a much d…"
"One might think this position (that the English colonialist should convert their Indian "brethren" to the Gospel) wou…"
"His accomplishments and large body of admirers notwithstanding, Jones's reputation has slipped in recent years, parti…"
"First, the hypothesis for which Sir William Jones is most famous had deep antecedents and was always problematic. Mos…"
""Scholars from Sir William Jones to the PRESENT imagined this group (Aryans aka Indo-Europeans) as their most ancient…"