"The first writer to attribute this proposition to Pythagoras is Vitruvius, hardly a reliable witness. From then on, this account became more widespread, but always in connection with the famous hecatomb that Pythagoras is said to have offered in celebration of discovering the proposition—an anecdote that severely undermines the credibility of the entire story. This sacrifice is incompatible with the strict prohibition of all bloody sacrifices, which writers of the same period, indeed often the very same ones who elsewhere recount the hecatomb, have handed down to us from the Pythagorean ritual laws. Cicero himself took offense at this anecdote, and in the latest Neopythagorean tradition, the bloody sacrifice is replaced by that of an ox formed from flour. For this reason, the hecatomb is not only incongruous with the Pythagoreans, but also with the Pythagoreans themselves. Proclus, an insightful writer, expresses himself remarkably vaguely: ‘When we listen to those who want to tell old stories, we find that they trace this theorem back to Pythagoras.’ As this shows, he too was unaware of any reliable source."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Hermann Hankel (1839-1873) Hankel 1874: 97-98) Hankel, Hermann. Zur Geschichte der Mathematik in Alterthum und Mittelalter, Leipzig 1874.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Pythagorean_theorem
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Pythagorean theorem
10 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Pythagorean theorem →
Related Quotes
"Though this is the proposition universally associated by tradition with the name of Pythagoras, no really trustworthy…"
"The cord stretched in the diagonal of an oblong produces both [areas] which the cords forming the longer and shorter …"
"The diagonal cord of a rectangle makes both (the squares) that the vertical side and the horizontal side make separat…"
"Some of the things, which belong particularly to the history of mathematics, we will not refrain from attributing to …"
"In the Shulba Sutra appended to Baudhayana’s Shrauta Sutra, mathematical instructions are given for the construction …"
"‘These operations are all founded on a very distinct conception of what happens in the case of an eclipse, and on the…"
"If we listen to those who like to record antiquities, we shall find them attributing this theorem to Pythagoras and s…"
"It is more likely that Pythagoras was influenced by India than by Egypt. Almost all the theories, religions, philosop…"
"If we consider the results obtained together, we will not be able to doubt the conclusion to be drawn from them. The …"
"The process of reasoning called "Mathematical Induction" has had several independent origins. It has been traced back…"