"On the other hand, when sticking to the text is what will advance the judgment, they become strict constructionists. Some of the most conspicuous instances of this can be found in judgments relating to Article 30, the article that deals with the ‘right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions’. The country had been partitioned on the cry that Muslims will never be secure in a united India. The framers were naturally keen to reassure the minorities that they would be free to preserve their religion, language and culture. Accordingly, Article 29 was enacted guaranteeing them and assuring them of this freedom. In case they wanted to set up institutions for safeguarding their language, culture, religion, Article 30 was enacted assuring them that ‘All minorities, whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice.’ The context made the purpose clear: minorities would have the freedom to set up such institutions as they thought would best preserve their culture, religion, language. But, given what has been the climate of discourse since the framing of the Constitution, the judges became literalists. Minorities would have the right to set up and manage ‘educational institutions of their choice’ irrespective of the purpose for which the institution was set up. Thus, engineering colleges and dental colleges set up by a family of, say, Muslims would have freedoms from state regulation and oversight that engineering and dental colleges set up by run-of-the-mill Indians would not."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Imported from EN Wikiquote
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Arun_Shourie
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Arun Shourie
136 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Arun Shourie →
Related Quotes
"Then we have our seedy Leftists busy abusing each other. And finally we have the liberals - busy rearranging furnitur…"
"To rely on these fellows to save us from the impending fascist avalanche is to rely on superannuated buffaloes to see…"
"Thus silence retards reform. If large numbers were writing and talking about the communalism of these leaders, for in…"
"And yet I find in the majority judgement a fatal innocence... The judgement quotes the proclamations from the Rig, Ya…"
"The forfeiture is exactly the sort of thing which has landed us where we are : where intellectual inquiry is shut out…"
"They rely on intimidation, It is exactly by tactics of this kind that an earlier book of Mr. Swarup - Understanding I…"
"For fifty years this bunch has been suppressing facts and inventing lies. How concerned they are about that objective…"
"All the facts ... were well known fifty years ago. With the passing of the generation that fought for Independence, w…"
"The most telling illustration has been provided by the silence over the new archaeological findings. .... When the fi…"
"What we are witnessing today in relation to the criminals of the Emergency is not the rule of law but the destruction…"