"Arguments about gender are now so vicious that most high-profile people would rather eat their hair than speak out. But sport, it turns out, is a more clear-cut issue to some than, say, prisons – where various groups have argued over whether trans women should be housed with female inmates. The current ideology is that gender identity is at least as important, if not more so, than biological sex. That is why an LGBT sports group like Athlete Ally can dismiss Navratilova's arguments about male skeletal advantages with a simple "trans women are women". The International Olympic Committee allows trans women to compete if they have been reducing their testosterone for 12 months; but, increasingly, female athletes are saying that testosterone is not the only advantage. Boys start growing bigger bones, muscles and greater heart capacity from puberty, and no gender switch will undo that. One can firmly defend a person's right to live in the gender identity of their choosing yet also look at photos of trans women athletes such as Gabrielle Ludwig, Natalie van Gogh and [[w:Rachel McKinnon|[Rachel] McKinnon]] standing alongside their strikingly smaller female team-mates, and think Navratilova’s arguments are worth investigating instead of dismissing with cries of bigotry."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Jews from the United KingdomJews from the United StatesWomen authors from EnglandJournalists from EnglandFeminists from England
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
"Sport can help to clarify the trans debate" The Guardian (6 March 2019)
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Hadley_Freeman
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Hadley Freeman
60 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Hadley Freeman →
Related Quotes
"An eating disorder is a mental illness. It is characterised by the sufferer's belief that they are too fat, that to s…"
"The relationship between Britain and America, from Britain's perspective, has always reminded me of the one between F…"
"This week George Galloway took to his video blog, the apparently unironically named Good Night with George Galloway, …"
"It was, if memory serves, the Louis Vuitton fashion show and I was there in my very professional capacity as a fashio…"
"First, it is important to remember we are dealing with interactions on social media here, a medium that is to "calm" …"
"And speaking of wealthy, scary people, who should arrive but [[w:Harvey Weinstein|[Harvey] Weinstein]] himself. "Mr W…"
"Taran-tara! A book is being published this month, and it has already attracted the kind of publicity that would make …"
"What a strange, Alice-through-the-looking-glass time it is to be a liberal American Jew in Britain. When I was growin…"
"Jews are not Israel (something liberal Jews have been saying for years) but nobody – not a London theatre, not even S…"
"My life and internet bandwidth are too limited to fight with Assange’s online army of defenders about his politics, b…"