"Opponents of democracy are continually raising two sets of objections which they deem fatal. First, they say, you cannot get the general will of the people really dominant in politics, whatever forms of franchise or election you devise, and if you could, the welfare, even the existence of the state would be constantly imperilled. Secondly, they say, if a sound democracy is possible, it can only be confined to so small a group of men as to be unfitted to the needs of modern society which demand large states. Hence, they proceed to argue, though a nation may be furnished with a tolerably complete democracy in its constitution, the complexity of a modern civilised government converts it into a practical bureaucracy, controlled, as all governments have ever been controlled, by an oligarchy of rich men. It is primarily because the Swiss Constitution claims to have provided an escape from this paralysing imbroglio, and to have attested experimentally the possibility of democracy, that it deserves the attention of other nations which are trying to be democracies and failing. The direct participation of a simple citizen in acts of government, and the application of the federal principle, are the keynotes to Swiss democracy. By means of the former it is claimed that those monstrous excrescences of "party," known as bosses and machine politicians, cannot thrive, while the latter prevents the growth of those not less dangerous abuses that proceed from the complex machinery of a highly centralised government in a large state. Let the body of free citizens not merely elect men who shall execute their will in making laws and in other acts of government, but retain the right of directing what laws shall or shall not be passed, what acts shall or shall not be done by their representatives; these checks upon the abuse of power by individual representatives or parties are, it is contended, necessary and sufficient securities for the free play of the general will."
Quote Details
Added by wikiquote-import-bot
Unverified quote
0 likes
Original Language: English
Available Languages (1)
Sources
Henry Demarest Lloyd, The Swiss Democracy: The Study of a Sovereign People (1908) p. 6.
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Direct_democracy
Revision History
No revisions have been submitted for this quote.
Categories
Direct democracy
33 quotes on TrueQuotesView all quotes by Direct democracy →
Related Quotes
"We no longer use the word "democracy" as the founders of our government used it, as meaning a government in which the…"
"Why direct government has grown in favor. This increase in the power of the voters has been due to two main causes: (…"
"The initiative and referendum are schemes for allowing the voters to make laws directly without using the legislature…"
"There is... a peculiar interest... in surveying the institutions of those countries which in our own time have carrie…"
"The introduction of the referendum in Switzerland constitutes one of the chief victories of the principle of direct g…"
"Among the modern democracies which are true democracies, Switzerland has the highest claim... It is the oldest, for i…"
"Most of the American State Constitutions depart further from English precedents than do those of the Australian State…"
"Athenian democracy was different from the much later American form, not only because it was the expression of a singl…"
"Direct democracy, made possible by the Internet, does not only relate to popular consultations, but to a new centrali…"
"The milieu in which creativity can be developed is principally the field of culture, and Beuys starts his sociopoliti…"