Psychologists

"Homer and Shakespeare lived in very different times, more than two thousand years apart, but they both captured the same idea; we are not all equally intelligent. I suspect that anyone who has failed to notice this is somewhat out of touch with the species."

"The study of intelligence is not an isolated academic topic; our intelligence has social consequences. We want our leaders to be intelligent, and exhibit concern if we think they are not. There were politically motivated attacks on the intelligence of Presidents Lincoln, Truman, Harding, and Ford. Seri¬ ous concerns about mental competence"

"Concerns about intelligence are not confined to concerns about our leaders. Our school systems use cognitive tests to stream high school students into different pro¬ grams. Colleges use cognitive tests to screen applicants for higher education programs. These tests are never called “intelligence tests,” but they correlate highly with them."

"Testing is not confined to the educational system. Volunteers for the United States military services must obtain passing scores on a test of general mental competence, the Armed Forces Qualifying Test (AFQT)."

"We built a science of wellbeing for people who don't exist."

"Our models are built on population averages, but the average person is a statistical ghost."

"We must protect people's ability to author their own lives."

"AI systems built without psychological grounding are not just ineffective. They are causing harm at scale."

"An AI system that measures your mind without consent is surveillance. An AI system that changes your mind without safety guards is malpractice."

"Psychology is not a compliance checkbox engineers have to tick off. It is the fundamental safety architecture that allows digital health and wellbeing interventions to scale responsibly."

"We are the last generation that will influence what wellbeing means before AI systems optimize it for us anyway."

"This is concerning because the difference between optimizing measurable correlates of wellbeing and supporting genuine wellbeing is the difference between creating a meaningful life vs. an efficiently managed one."

"Wellbeing is not something to be optimized. Wellbeing is something humans must be able to author themselves."

"A life one never struggles to choose is a life someone else is choosing for you."

"Connection that costs nothing builds nothing."

"The field that defines wellbeing in the age of AI will not be the one with the most citations or the longest history. It will be the first one that shows up at the design table with frameworks engineers can actually understand and use."

"Fluency does not equate to technical understanding."

"The profession’s cognitive ecosystem is changing faster than the profession can understand or regulate."

"To a psychologist, an eloquent response feels like understanding, even when it is merely computational."

"Psychologists are deploying tools they cannot audit and accepting recommendations they cannot justify."

"Our practical skills are fading. Not because we’re getting dumber, but because the machines are getting too good."

"In other words, you’re performing. But you’re not learning."

"A good test of expertise isn’t how someone performs when everything’s working. It’s how they respond when it’s not."

"Because the smartest tool in the room… should still be the human."

"We’re watching the emergence of a digital therapeutic co-dependency crisis."

"Your clients are forming attachments to systems that validate without challenging."

"My dear colleagues, that model is dead."

"There’s now a third entity in the room."

"Credentials are permission to practice, not competence itself."

"Positive psychology has, in its pursuit of generalizability and standardization, marginalized the lived experiences of individuals."

"We argue that the field has drifted into a 'science of averages' that can overlook, and at times harm, the very people it hopes to help."

"The level of statistical significance in a large experiment reveals very little about how or why specific individuals experienced change."

"As such, this special issue and editorial are bold calls for a paradigm shift from universal to unique, from prescribed to personalized."

"Psychology is in the midst of a crisis of confidence."

"Positive psychology (PP) is not immune to the credibility crisis."

"Positive psychology does not seem to conform to the definition of a pseudoscience."

"POP 2.0 is defined as an evidence-based, data-driven field of scientific inquiry that embraces technological developments, design principles, and innovations."

"The future of POP hangs in the balance, teetering on the precipice between a potential revolution or an impending downfall."

"This necessitates shifting practitioners’ roles from facilitators to developers, focusing on becoming data-driven technologists and analysts."

"This, in turn, has negatively affected positive psychology’s scientific credibility and public perception."

"However, within these criticisms and critiques lies unique opportunities to channel future growth and development of the discipline."